Home Invites Blogs Careers Chat Events Forums Groups Members News Photos Polls Singles Videos
Home > Blogs > Post Content

History and Linguistics (1754 hits)


Aada koy detngna woni (Fulfulde)
Lammii ay dekkal demb (Wolof)
Speech is what gives shape to the past
 
The African sees a link between history and language. This view is common to Bantu, Yoruba and Mande. But that is not its originality.
 
Indeed, an Arab or a Greek before the time of Thucydides would certainly agree with the Fulani dictum that 'narrative is where we meet the past': Hanki koy daarol awratee.
 
What is special about the link between history and language in the African tradition lies in the view of history and language to which that tradition, on the whole, has adhered.
 
Language and thought are often identified, and history is seen not as science but as wisdom and as an art of living.
 
History aims at knowledge of the past. Linguistics is a science of language and speech. Historical narrative and historical works are contents and forms of thought. Language itself is the medium and prop of such thought.
 
Thus, obviously, linguistics and history each have their domain, their particular subject-matter and their methods. Nevertheless, there is interaction between them, at least from two points of view.
 
Language as a system and tool of communication is a historical phenomenon. It has its own history. As the medium of thought, and that of the past and knowledge of the past, it is the channel and the most important source of historical evidence. Thus linguistics, used here in its widest sense, covers an area of research which supplies history with at least two kinds of data: first, linguistic information properly speaking; and secondly, evidence which might be termed supra-linguistic. Linguistics can be used to see beyond the evidence of thought, beyond the conceptual apparatus used in a language and the oral or written evidence, to the history of men and their civilizations.
 
Once the problem is thus defined, it is easier to see what common ground there is between the historian and the linguist working on Africa. 
 

- Pathe Diagne (Senegal); Doctor of Political and Economic Science; linguist; author of two works on African political power and on Wolof grammar; Assistant Professor at the University of Dakar.

Posted By: Steve Williams
Saturday, February 21st 2015 at 8:05AM
You can also click here to view all posts by this author...

Report obscenity | post comment
Share |
Please Login To Post Comments...
Email:
Password:

 
Tarana ou l'amérique précolombienne - un continent africain
Pathé Diagne
À propos de ce produit
Tarana est le nom qu'utilisait avant les conquêtes européennes pour désigner leur continent les natifs africains restés Outre-atlantique, mais en contact avec l'Afrique de leurs origines grâce à une navigation séculaire permanente. Ces populations natives africaines sont fondatrices des grandes civilisations précolombiennes, des "Têtes de Nègres géantes" que découvrira Christophe Colomb. Ces mêmes populations natives vont résister dès 1492 aux conquistadores mercenaires blancs et noirs.

Saturday, February 21st 2015 at 9:34AM
Steve Williams

Does Pathe Diagne use an African Asian Language in his Intellectualization of History, Scholarship and Science?

OR

Does Pathe Diagne use the europeanColonization Language to define his History, Scholarship and Science....?

If it is the latter, any philosophicalLanguage of europeanRacism will do for his ramblings......

Tarana oder präkolumbianischen Amerika - eine afrikanischen Kontinent Pathé Diagne über dieses Produkt, das Tarana ist die Bezeichnung vor der Europäischen Eroberung ihres Kontinents benennen aus Atlantik afrikanischen Eingeborenen blieben aber in Kontakt mit ihren Wurzeln durch eine Jahrhunderte alte Navigation Afrika permanent. Afrikanische heimischen Populationen sind Gründung der präkolumbianischen Zivilisationen, eine "riesige Köpfe der Neger" entdeckte Christophe Colomb. Diese


Saturday, February 21st 2015 at 12:08PM
robert powell
Even the task of simply listing all African languages is fraught with difficulties. Work on such a list has not yet achieved any very precise results. At a rough estimate there are in Africa between 1300 and 1500 systems of speech which may be classified as languages. Progress has certainly been made in recent years, though the right climate does not yet exist for a really thorough work of synthesis since some languages have still to be precisely identified and accurately analysed, and until this has been done they can hardly be classified.

A few specific examples will serve to illustrate the depth of the controversy and the extent of the uncertainty.

The first two examples concern the dialects to be found on the present geographical frontier of the Hamito-Semitic family and the black African family. The third concerns the West Atlantic (or Senegal-Guinea) group.

From the work of Meinhof,16 Delafosse,17 Meek,18 Lucas,19 and Cohen,20 to that of Greenberg in 1948, A. N. Tucker and M. A. Bryan in 1966,21 and the recent criticisms of T. Obenga,22 it emerges that there is no complete agreement either on the data, the method of classification, the members of the groups or the genesis and character of the relationships of the languages between the Nile and the Chad basin. Yet geography, in particular, and proximity unquestionably give these languages a real unity. The age-old parallel existence of black African and Semitic languages has led to a large stock of mutual borrowings. These two-way contributions make it difficult to draw the line between the original stock and outside acquisitions. The problem is to know whether the vocabulary proper to ancient Egyptian, Hausa, Coptic, Baghirmian, Sara and the Chadic languages that occurs in Berber and in Semitic languages such as Arabic and Amharic is evidence of a family relationship or simply of borrowing.

Data for ancient Egyptian goes back 4000 years and that for Semitic 2500 years. Comparable analysis of Chadic, Berber and Cu****ic does not exist for times prior to the nineteenth or twentieth centuries of our era.

In 1947 M. Cohen published his Essai comparatif sur le vocabulaire et la phonétique du Chamito-sémitique, in which he compares Egyptian, Berber, Semitic, Cu****ic and Hausa (to which he makes occasional reference). In 1949 Leslau23 and Hintze24 began to challenge Cohen's findings and even to question his methods. J. H. Greenberg, having in mind that the very notion of a Hamito-Semitic group was disputed, widened the range of its components. He suggested a separate fifth member, Chadic, and renamed the whole group Hamitic, and later, Afro-Asiatic. These conclusions provoked controversy from the moment of their publication. Polotsky25 doubted whether it was possible at present to accept the existence of five branches. Greenberg, be it noted, repeated (still without carrying conviction) the predominantly geographical thesis about Chadic and its connections which he put forward in an article in Languages of the World. One only needs to refer to the contradictory classifications of Greenberg, Tucker and Bryan, constantly brought into question even by the authors themselves, to gain an idea of the inconclusive nature of their proposals.

Recent work gives substance to the notion of a Chadic family, the borders of which extend far beyond the shores of the lake. Newman and Ma26 in 1966 and Illie Svityè27 in 1967 have improved our knowledge of proto-Chadic. The work of Y. P. Caprille28 has charted its expansion in Chad itself. On the basis of systematic observation, a genetic link might be suggested between the Sara and Chadic groups and several languages classified as West Atlantic (Serer, Fulfulde, Wolof, Safen, etc.).29 These attributions alone cast doubt upon the whole attempt at classification, as is emphasized by C. T. Hodge in an excellent article.30 The major problem of the nature of the links between the languages of the frontier between the black African and the Hamito-Semitic languages remains unresolved. The sheer volume of published work that identifies the world of African culture with Semitic is a further problem.

There is still a problem of the membership and even of the identity of the black African language family. The symposium on 'The Peopling of Ancient Egypt', organized by Unesco in Cairo in 1974, emphasized this. On this occasion Professor.S. Sauneron recalled, by way of illustrating these uncertainties, that 'The Egyptian language could not be isolated from its African context and its origin could not be fully explained in terms of Semitic' (Final Report, p. 29).

Monday, February 23rd 2015 at 8:08AM
Steve Williams
History is the favourite haunt of ideology. Ideology develops around and within it. The earliest works on the African past and on African languages coincided with the European colonial expansion. Such works were strongly tainted with the contemporary notions of racial supremacy.

The ethnocentric viewpoint was the natural expression of the need to judge the value of any civilization by internal reference. It led men to appropriate to themselves the most distinctive points of any civilization in order to legitimize their world dominance in thought and power. The theories of the primacy of the civilizing Indo-European, Aryan or white man are evidence of excesses which still today leave profound reverberations in a number of works on African history and linguistics.

Monday, February 23rd 2015 at 10:58AM
Steve Williams
Please Login To Post Comments...
Email:
Password:

 
More From This Author
LETTERS TO TRUMP
Why was the public not told when they were discovered in November?
McCarthy thanks Trump after House speaker vote: 'He was with me from the beginning'
Donald Trump's 'Digital Trading Cards' Sold Out In One Day — Netting $4.4 Million
AFPAC II (2021) Nick Fuentes Full Speech
Ousted Twitter counsel Jim Baker vetted 'Twitter Files' without Elon Musk's knowledge, Matt Taibbi reveals
Herschel Walker Interview at First Baptist Atlanta
Nick Fuentes is not a White Supremacist
Forward This Blog Entry!
Blogs Home

(Advertise Here)
Who's Online
>> more | invite 
Black America Resources
100 Black Men of America
www.100blackmen.org

Black America's Political Action Committee (BAMPAC)
www.bampac.org

Black America Study
www.blackamericastudy.com

Black America Web
www.blackamericaweb.com

CNN Black In America Special
www.cnn.com/blackinamerica

NUL State of Black America Report
www.nul.org

Most Popular Bloggers
agnes levine has logged 24426 blog subscribers!
reginald culpepper has logged 12051 blog subscribers!
miisrael bride has logged 8216 blog subscribers!
tanisha grant has logged 5633 blog subscribers!
rickey johnson has logged 4788 blog subscribers!
>> more | add 
Latest Jobs
NETWORK ENGINEER with Arizona State University in Tempe, AZ.
SENIOR NETWORK ENGINEER with Arizona State University in Tempe, AZ.
DOC State School Teacher - Multiple Endorsements & Facilities - State of Connecticut - Accepting applications through 1/21/26 with State of Connecticut - Department of Correction, Unified School District #1 in Various locations in CT, CT.
Advanced Manufacturing Vocational Instructor - State of Connecticut - Accepting applications through 2/2/26 with State of Connecticut - Department of Correction, Unified School District #1 in Various locations in , CT.
Hospitality Vocational Instructor - State of Connecticut (Accepting applications through 2/2/26) with State of Connecticut - Department of Correction, Unified School District #1 in Various locations in , CT.
>> more | add