Betrayal of the open Internet-A Message from Color Of Change
When the FCC tells you that the rules they voted on yesterday will protect openness and freedom on the Internet, don't believe the hype. The FCC's chairman may call what passed yesterday "net neutrality," but we know better.
The rules -- written to placate the broadband industry -- would give Internet service providers unprecedented power to profit through online discrimination, all at the expense of regular people.
This is beyond disappointing. President Obama promised us net neutrality,1 but what we got yesterday is far less -- it's fake net neutrality. This isn't a charge we level lightly. The proposal has serious loopholes that undermine the FCC's ability to protect many of us from broadband company abuses. Specifically:2
1. They enshrine different rules for wired and wireless Internet -- allowing big corporations to slow down or block websites and applications on your mobile phone.
2. They allow Internet service providers to set up tollbooths online, stifling new innovators who can't pay the fees the big corporations can.
3. For the first time, they embrace a tiered Internet -- a public Internet with publishing access for regular people vs. a private one controlled by major corporations, where they will shift future dollars for investment and innovation. In the new net, participation will based on the ability to pay corporate gatekeepers and not threatening their business interests. It will spell the end of the Internet as we know it.
In addition, it's not clear that the FCC will have the legal authority to enforce even these watered-down rules. Because Genachowski chose not to reclassify broadband, the rules could be struck down by courts. And Verizon is already contemplating a legal challenge.3
Despite these glaring shortcomings, President Obama and the FCC still call this net neutrality -- to telecom industry applause.4 It would be funny if it weren't so sad.
There's no denying that this is a real setback for our movement and our democracy. But the fight isn't over yet. As challenges to the new regulations arise, as the broadband industry tests the limits of the new laws, and as Congressional Republicans attempt to keep the FCC from ever enforcing net neutrality rules, we'll have new opportunities to fight for a free and open Internet. Thanks for being with us.
Until then, there's one concrete thing you can do to help. President Obama and Chairman Genachowski will continue to say they've passed real net neutrality rules in a cynical attempt to claim the fulfillment of a campaign promise. It's critical that we not let this narrative take hold. Please read this blog post by our friend Jason Rosenbaum of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, and share it with everyone you know:
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/632?akid=1...
Thanks and Peace,
-- James, Gabriel, William, Dani, Natasha and the rest of the ColorOfChange.org team
December 22nd, 2010

Anita:
Thank you for explaining this issue in a clear way.