A Chicago teacher has upset parents by showing ‘The Middle Passage’ to fourth-graders.
Is a Graphic Slavery Film Too Much for Nine-Year-Olds?
"Middle Passage" is a film that doesn't pull any punches.
The HBO-produced feature, directed by French film-maker Guy Deslauriers and starring Djimon Hounsou, describes in graphic detail the voyage of African slaves across the Atlantic to the New World. The brutal conditions aboard slave ships are tackled head-on; suicide and child rape are among the horrors depicted and discussed.
So when a teacher in Chicago's north suburbs showed the film to her fourth-grade students, some parents were not pleased.
"As a parent and father I was destroyed, in the sense that I felt incapacitated in protecting my child," said Patrick Livney, father of nine-year-old Becca, a student at the Greeley School in Winnetka where the film was shown. "The concept of a rape, suicide, depression at the age of 9 years old is a sad commentary," he said, according to CBS.
TribLocal spoke with Mark Friedman, interim co-superintendent of Winnetka schools. He said that officials were still investigating the matter, but that the district is taking concerns seriously.
The teacher apparently brought the film from home, which Friedman says was not against district policy. "We always say you need to use your judgment," he said.
But after a meeting yesterday, Winnetka School District 36 changed that policy. Now, teachers may only bring in G-rated supplemental materials, unless they seek administrative approval.
We have to agree with the parents here. It seems the very relevant lesson the teacher intended to convey with this film could be overshadowed by the shock of the being exposed to such graphic content for the first time (for black and white children alike).
There are plenty of ways to express the horrors of slavery -- families being torn apart, abysmal living conditions, and the very fact of human beings being owned -- in a way that can get through to elementary school kids without giving them nightmares. Not to mention, popping in a film seems like a shortcut around figuring out how to teach slavery through an age-appropriate and potentially more meaningful lesson plan.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/23/m...
What Say You??
Should 'Middle Passage' have been shown to nine-year-olds? Yes. It's important to expose kids to the realities of the slave trade, no matter how harsh.
No. Kids should be sheltered from that kind of brutality, at least at that young an age.
The HBO-produced feature, directed by French film-maker Guy Deslauriers and starring Djimon Hounsou, describes in graphic detail the voyage of African slaves across the Atlantic to the New World. The brutal conditions aboard slave ships are tackled head-on; suicide and child rape are among the horrors depicted and discussed.
So when a teacher in Chicago's north suburbs showed the film to her fourth-grade students, some parents were not pleased.
"As a parent and father I was destroyed, in the sense that I felt incapacitated in protecting my child," said Patrick Livney, father of nine-year-old Becca, a student at the Greeley School in Winnetka where the film was shown. "The concept of a rape, suicide, depression at the age of 9 years old is a sad commentary," he said, according to CBS.
TribLocal spoke with Mark Friedman, interim co-superintendent of Winnetka schools. He said that officials were still investigating the matter, but that the district is taking concerns seriously.
The teacher apparently brought the film from home, which Friedman says was not against district policy. "We always say you need to use your judgment," he said.
But after a meeting yesterday, Winnetka School District 36 changed that policy. Now, teachers may only bring in G-rated supplemental materials, unless they seek administrative approval.
We have to agree with the parents here. It seems the very relevant lesson the teacher intended to convey with this film could be overshadowed by the shock of the being exposed to such graphic content for the first time (for black and white children alike).
There are plenty of ways to express the horrors of slavery -- families being torn apart, abysmal living conditions, and the very fact of human beings being owned -- in a way that can get through to elementary school kids without giving them nightmares. Not to mention, popping in a film seems like a shortcut around figuring out how to teach slavery through an age-appropriate and potentially more meaningful lesson plan.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/23/m...
What Say You??
Should 'Middle Passage' have been shown to nine-year-olds? Yes. It's important to expose kids to the realities of the slave trade, no matter how harsh.
No. Kids should be sheltered from that kind of brutality, at least at that young an age.
I felt that its too, much for a child to handle if that child has been sheltered. I would want to prepare my little one first, but not all children are the same and have been exposed to much worst things, eh!